Valuetoner 67 XL Ink Cartridges Replacement for HP 67XL Black and Colour VS Original HP 67 Black Ink Cartridge | Works with HP DeskJet 1255

Valuetoner 67 XL Ink Cartridges Replacement for HP 67XL Black and Colour

Based on real customer feedback, expert product testing, and forum reviews from platforms like Walmart and Amazon CA, the Valuetoner 67XL Remanufactured Ink Cartridge 2-Pack is a highly popular, budget-friendly alternative to costly original HP ink.

It is widely used for home offices running HP Envy (like the 6455e, 6055, and 6052) and DeskJet series printers.However, because this is a third-party remanufactured product, it comes with a massive compatibility caveat that buyers need to know before purchasing.What Customers Say About Performance👍 The Pros: High Yield & Low CostStellar Value for Money: Reviewers consistently state that this combo pack costs roughly half the price of original HP cartridges while offering significantly more ink.Impressive Page Yields: Heavy users praise its longevity.

The black cartridge is rated for up to 705 pages and the tri-colour for 455 pages (at 5% standard coverage), which easily beats standard OEM capacity.Solid Print Quality: Everyday buyers printing text documents, shipping labels, and school homework report crisp black text and rich, smear-free colors.Upgraded Smart Chips: The manufacturer builds in updated chips so that most standard printers immediately recognize the cartridge and display accurate ink levels.👎 The Cons: The Crucial HP+ Software TrapThe "HP+ Active" Block: This is the most vital warning shared in user communities.

If you have an "e" series printer (like the Envy 6455e or 6010e) and you activated the HP+ service during setup, your printer will automatically block these third-party cartridges via cloud firmware updates.

Buyers caught in this trap report immediate error messages.Occasional "Non-Genuine" Warnings: Even on standard, non-HP+ printers, users note you may have to click past a generic firmware warning stating that a non-original cartridge was detected before it lets you print.Final VerdictThe Valuetoner 67XL Combo Pack is a fantastic, money-saving alternative for casual or heavy home printing—but ONLY if you do not use the HP+ service.Buy it if: You own a standard HP Envy or DeskJet model, or you have an "e" printer but skipped activating HP+ during setup.

You will get great text quality, way more pages, and save a significant chunk of money.Skip it if: You actively use HP+ or are currently enrolled in the HP Instant Ink monthly subscription program. The printer's firmware will likely lock out the cartridges, making them useless. In this scenario, you must stick to original HP 67XL Original Cartridges.

Original HP 67 Black Ink Cartridge | Works with HP DeskJet 1255

Based on aggregate customer feedback from major retailers like Walmart.ca and Amazon.ca, the Original HP 67 Black Ink Cartridge (3YM56AN) is a highly reliable but low-capacity baseline cartridge.

It is engineered primarily for casual users with HP DeskJet (1255, 2700, 4100) or HP Envy (6000, 6400) series home printers.The consensus among tens of thousands of buyers highlights a distinct trade-off between flawless immediate performance and high long-term operational costs.📋 Detailed Customer Insights👍 What Customers Love (The Pros)Zero Compatibility Hassles: Buyers appreciate that as an authentic OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) product, it is recognized instantly by the printer without triggering error messages, a common issue with third-party brands.Crisp, Professional Print Quality: Reviewers consistently praise the rich, dark ink flow.

It produces crisp text documents, clean shipping labels, and smear-free forms with laser-like precision.Instant Ink Seamless Integration: Users enrolled in HP's Instant Ink automated replenishment program report that this cartridge syncs perfectly with cloud tracking to trigger automated replacements right on time.👎 What Customers Complain About (The Cons)Incredibly Small Ink Volume: The most common criticism is the low physical ink capacity, which holds only about 2 mL of ink.Poor Page Yield for the Price: While officially rated for a maximum of 120 pages, many customers complain that real-world heavy printing (like multi-page school reports or dense documents) depletes the tank in as few as 40 to 50 pages.Low Value for Money: Users frequently state that buying standard-yield cartridges individually is the most expensive way to run a home printer over time.🏁 Final VerdictThe Standard HP 67 Black Cartridge is an excellent "peace-of-mind" choice for very light, occasional use, but a poor choice for active home offices.If your printing habits are limited to occasional boarding passes, tax documents, or a few forms a month, this cartridge is perfect because it guarantees no-fuss performance and pristine print quality.

However, if your printer sees weekly or daily action, buying this size will quickly feel like a money pit.💡 Recommendations for Better Value:For Moderate Users: Skip this standard version and buy the HP 67XL High-Yield Black Cartridge. It prints up to 240 pages (double the capacity) for a lower cost-per-page, saving you frequent trips to the store.For Frequent/Heavy Users: Actively take advantage of its Instant Ink eligibility.

Enrolling in an HP monthly plan can cut your cumulative ink costs by up to 50% compared to purchasing standard retail cartridges standalone.